Method v1.0
How we will run product tests
One method, versioned, with a protocol for each category. A ranking or measurement claim on this site has to cite a log that follows this method.
Rules that do not wait for a log
- No invented numbers, quotes, or results.
- Vendor claims stay labeled as vendor claims.
- Ownership is labeled on every brand we rank or review.
- Unpaid options can outrank paid ones.
- The build fails if a page claims a product test without a file in /data/.
Category protocols
VPN protocol
What we will measure when a VPN product test is run: leaks, setup, and behavior on the networks people actually use.
Travel-router protocol
Setup, VPN-client compatibility, and behavior on typical travel networks.
Faraday and RFID protocol
A simple, repeatable check of whether a bag or wallet blocks a phone call or a key-fob action — and the limits of that check.
Security-key protocol
Which sites and features a given YubiKey (or similar) actually supports, from a documented sign-in pass.
Encrypted USB protocol
Unlock behavior, platform support, and what happens if the device is unplugged mid-write — not a cryptography audit.
Local-storage camera protocol
Whether a camera can record and play back without a paid cloud plan, and what still leaves the house.
Data-removal protocol
A before-and-after check of listed broker listings, with a documented start date. Not a promise that a person will disappear from the internet.
Password-manager protocol
Import, export, and everyday sign-in on a fixed set of browsers and devices.
Encrypted-email protocol
Account setup, interoperability of encrypted messages, and what a message looks like to a non-user.
Secure-cloud-storage protocol
Install, a known-folder sync, sharing links, and whether a password reset can reveal file contents — as the vendor documents and as we can observe.
Ad-blocker protocol
A fixed set of pages, with and without the blocker, and a note of breakage.
eSIM and second-number protocol
Activation, inbound and outbound SMS or data, and what identity the vendor asks for.