Comparison

StartMail vs Proton Mail vs Tuta

By J.K. Ward (pen name) · Updated 2026-11-17· Method v1.0 · Test pending

A research comparison of three encrypted-email providers, from official documentation. Test pending.

StartMail, Proton Mail, and Tuta are paid (or freemium) email services that advertise encryption the provider is not supposed to be able to read. This page compares them from official documentation. It is not an inbox log, and encrypted email is not a cloak for metadata.

Tuta has no cash affiliate program we will use; the link is unpaid and Tuta is included on merit.

What “encrypted email” usually covers

In the usual design, the body of a message between two users of the same service is encrypted so the provider does not hold a readable copy. Details differ:

  • Mail to an ordinary Gmail or workplace inbox is often not end-to-end encrypted, unless a special notice, a guest portal, or a passworded message is used. Official docs for each provider describe that case. Read them before you assume a message is protected all the way.
  • Subject lines, sender, recipient, and timestamps are often less protected than the body, or not protected in the same way.
  • Recovery, if you lose a password, can conflict with a “we cannot read your mail” claim. A recovery path that lets the provider reset access may also be a path that changes the threat model. Official recovery documentation is the source, not a slogan.

How the three describe themselves

StartMail. Official materials describe a paid, Netherlands-based encrypted mailbox, with IMAP access in the documented setup and a focus on a familiar mail-client workflow. There is no widely advertised free tier on the same terms as Proton’s or Tuta’s; confirm current plans on the official site.

Proton Mail. Official materials, from Proton AG, describe a Switzerland-based service with a free tier and paid plans, web and mobile apps, and a broader Proton account that can include VPN, Drive, and Pass. Interoperability, aliases, and custom domains are plan-dependent; the official plan comparison is the authority.

Tuta (Tutao GmbH, Germany). Official materials describe encrypted mail (and a calendar) with a free tier and paid plans, and a design that also encrypts subject lines in Tuta-to-Tuta mail, per their documentation. IMAP is not offered in the same way as a conventional host; you typically use their apps. That is a genuine workflow difference, not a footnote.

Other choice factors, still from docs

  • Jurisdiction and company. Netherlands, Switzerland, and Germany are different legal environments. This is not legal advice; it is a reason to read the provider’s own transparency and policy pages.
  • Aliases and custom domains. If you need you@yourdomain, check the plan, not a blog post from three years ago.
  • Import and export. Leaving a provider is part of choosing one. Official export tools and their limits belong in your decision.
  • Ownership. Proton Mail is part of Proton AG, alongside Proton VPN, Drive, and Pass. StartMail is StartMail B.V. Tuta is Tutao GmbH. See the ownership map.

How we will compare later

The encrypted-email protocol logs setup, a message between two accounts at the same provider, and a message to an ordinary mailbox. Until that exists, we will not invent a winner.

Sources

What we did not test

No Privacy Proven product test has been run for this page. Figures and feature lists come from official documentation or cited public sources and should be read as such. We do not invent results, rankings from measurements we did not take, or quotes.