Comparison

Data-broker removal: DIY vs Incogni vs Optery vs DeleteMe

By J.K. Ward (pen name) · Updated 2026-11-17· Method v1.0 · Test pending

How paid removal services differ from doing opt-outs yourself, from public documentation. Not legal advice. Test pending.

Data brokers and people-search sites collect and republish personal information. You can send opt-out requests yourself, or you can pay a service to send and recrawl them. This page compares those paths using official documentation from Incogni, Optery, and DeleteMe. It is not legal advice, it is not a promise of removal, and it is not a before-and-after log.

What “removal” can and cannot mean

  • A broker may honor an opt-out, then relist you later when a new file arrives.
  • Coverage is a list of brokers, not “the internet.” Sites, court records, social networks, and news articles are often out of scope.
  • A dashboard percentage is a vendor’s own metric unless a log shows the same listings you started with.

Anyone who tells you that a service will make you disappear is overselling. We will not.

Doing it yourself

Many brokers publish opt-out forms. The work is to find them, prove you are the person in the listing, track dates, and come back when the listing returns. Public-interest projects such as opt-out guides and independently maintained broker lists exist for this; they are worth reading alongside any paid dashboard. DIY costs time rather than a subscription. It also teaches you which brokers actually listed you, which a black-box service can hide.

DIY is a reasonable choice if you have a short list of listings and the patience to recrawl. It is a poor choice only if someone is selling you hopelessness as a reason to skip it.

Incogni. Official materials describe a removal service that contacts brokers for you on a subscription. Incogni is in the Nord Security / Surfshark group and is also offered as part of a broader Surfshark bundle, which is an ownership fact, not a quality score.

Optery. Official materials describe a mix of DIY tools and managed removal, with different plan tiers for how much the company does on your behalf. That split is useful if you want to see the broker list and still hand off the sending.

DeleteMe. Official materials describe a long-running paid removal service, including family plans, with regular reports. DeleteMe is a product of Abine.

We have not enrolled a test identity in these services, so we will not invent recrawl times, success rates, or “worth it” math. Pricing changes and is not hard-coded here; read the vendor’s current page.

How we will compare later

The data-removal protocol starts with a dated list of listings, then re-checks the same brokers after a stated interval. That is the only way a “this service did better” sentence will appear on this site. Independent sites already do careful work in this category; when we cite them, we will name them.

A decision frame, without a winner

  • If you want to understand the list and you have time, start with DIY, even if you later pay someone.
  • If you want a managed recrawl and you accept a subscription, compare the current broker lists, plan terms, and cancellation rules on the official pages — not a screenshot from last year.
  • Look at ownership and bundles (Incogni’s place in the Nord / Surfshark group is an example) so you know who you are paying.
  • Keep your own export or screenshots. Do not rely only on a vendor dashboard.

Sources

  • Official product and help documentation from Incogni, Optery, and DeleteMe.
  • Our method and ownership map.
  • Independent comparison work in this category exists (for example opt-out watchdogs); we will cite specific pages when we rely on them for a fact.

What we did not test

No Privacy Proven product test has been run for this page. Figures and feature lists come from official documentation or cited public sources and should be read as such. We do not invent results, rankings from measurements we did not take, or quotes.